Friday 18 March 2011

Lessons from Fort Albany


My hometown has many First Nations community groups and also serves as a commercial hub for all the communities in Ontario’s far north. For years I’ve been very interested in the challenges facing First Nations peoples in the north – many isolated reserve communities face huge challenges in education, infrastructure, health, and so forth, yet most Canadians are unaware of this. Although I’m studying International Development, my goal is to apply my knowledge locally and work with Canadian communities. In this post I want to talk briefly about my experience visiting the northern community of Fort Albany.

I travelled to Fort Albany in 2009 with the Timmins MNR Far North team. The purpose of the weekend visit was to allow a face-to-face meeting with members of the community and MNR staff where a number of things would be discussed, including but not limited to some new policy changes, animal and fish population tracking, water quality in the Albany River, and band council and elder concerns.

We took an 8-seater plane on a 5 hour flight to Fort Albany from Timmins. Upon our arrival, we were screened for H1N1 and given information packages about the virus. At the time, there was great concern over the fact that isolated First Nations populations seemed to be more susceptible to H1N1 than other Canadian demographic groups.

Most discussion was through a translator, as many of the elders were not fluent in English, and the MNR staff (and I) were not fluent in Cree. The meeting lasted for several hours, during which I was taken aback many times over the differences between how such a meeting would proceed in any ‘Western’ town, as opposed to a Aboriginal community.

Near the end of the meeting between the MNR and the Fort Albany community leaders, the floor was opened up for general discussion. A community elder introduced as Gilbert stood up and spoke for about 45min (about an hour and a half with a translator).

He told us about how the whitefish in Albany River have become slimy and sick compared to how they were in his youth, and how the river had become dirty and cloudy. He knew that there was a greater amount of sediment in the water because he could no longer make tea from river water by letting the sediment settle to the bottom of his teapot – the water was just too murky. Finally, he spoke about a place where the river was eroding the edge of a cemetery and how coffins and bones were becoming uncovered (I was shocked to hear this).

The reverence with which the other community members and the MNR staff listened to his discussion made me think, ‘This is the way it should be’. Often we – Westerners - brush off the opinions of older generations as being old-fashioned or uneducated, when really we should be listening and learning. This cultural difference reminded me that I was a ‘Western’ visitor to the local Native culture.

Fort Albany, ON is located about 450km north of Timmins on the Shore of the Albany River, near James Bay.




8 comments:

  1. What were the major differences at the meeting? Besides the language barriers of course....

    Wow, to have a cemetery eroding and have no one doing anything about it? That's shocking! Was there any follow-up? Did the MNR staff send someone to investigate?

    Delightful post as usual Tal.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Tallia! That must have been such an interesting encounter! Really eye-opening.
    How come you went on the trip with MNR? Were you working there? How long were you gone for?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi ladies!

    To answer your questions...

    Lauren, a huge difference was the tone and pace of the meeting. All topics were discussed at length, and most of the discussion was anecdotal. This was an interesting contrast to 'Western' style meetings, in which participants maintain strict rules on procedure and timelines (for example, Roberts' Rules of Order). I was told that follow-up will occur for the cemetery as soon as funding and equipment could be arranged. I do not know how long that took, though due to the isolation and relative poverty of the community compared to southern communities, it definitely took longer than it should - this problem should never have occurred in the first place.

    Sheila, I went on this weekend visit as a interested individual. I had some contacts at the MNR when I was a summer student there a couple years earlier. I contacted my friends there and asked if there was room for me on their next trip north, because I was interested in learning more about the northern First Nations communities - mainly Fort Albany, Attawapiskat, and Kashechewan. I was also invited to travel to Moosonee and Moose Factory with another group, but unfortunately I had a scheduling conflict.

    Thanks for your questions, I appreciate the interest shown in my post!

    Tallia

    ReplyDelete
  4. Tallia, really interesting post. I think that we as Westerners have gotten into a habit of rushing and getting straight to the point when there is so much to learn about how you got there and the experiences along the way.
    I think we will experience similar eye-opening experiences on our placements that really make us question the way we do things now and motivate us to slow down and listen a little.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tallia, I think we are going to face the same long but useful meetings with people who do not speak our language. But the knowledge of the elders is known as Traditional Ecological Knowledge if you remember ERS classes. As I always thought the people are the one we should listen to and you did, because they know what the problem is and how to fix it but short of things that help them. Did you see the skulls and bones? If you did not, in Africa if you go to a grave yard you will see so many so do not worry we will see some in Ghana.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Teshager

    No, I didn't see the actual bones - to be honest, I don't think I would have wanted to. While it is a reality I may have to face in Ghana, I think seeing human remains would be upsetting - it's not an experience I hope for!

    Tallia

    ReplyDelete
  7. That sounds like an amazing opportunity Tallia! You and lucky to have had those connections to allow you to go on that trip!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yes, it scary and sad to see human beings dead but it shows that how fragile we are and how we are like leaves in the Autumn.
    But to see the mummies in Egypt is not that scary and the old fossiles in Ethiopia. Those things we dream to find one. Anyways your blog was very interesting. Peace.

    ReplyDelete